Friday 26 November 2010

Why Rebbe Schneerson Hates Islam?

This interview with Rebbe Menachem Schneerson, in 1980 for the radio station, Kol Yisrael, by broadcaster, Motti Eden, exposes to the world the mental, moral and spiritual degradation reflected in the way of thinking, and mode of operating of Jewish-zionist occupiers.
The “highly respected” , “world renowned” Rebbe, explains with anguish and grief how their methods of bribery and moral corruption ceased to work with Palestinian Muslims.
How dare Palestinians “break the heart” of the Talmudic Rebbe and not accept his bribery?
Have they no feelings?
How dare they refuse his enticement money and sexual inducement?
How dare they become more passionate about their faith?
How dare they become more zealous about their independent?
How dare they endure their trauma with dignity and continue to give and sacrifice?

http://www.crownheights.info/index.php/index.php?itemid=30072






Quote:
“according to the intelligence I have from Washington – where intelligence is gathered from all over the world- the situation is most extremely grave. For two reasons: there is a trend growing daily amongst the Arabs…
thirty or forty years ago, for just a few Liras, or just a few Dollars, it was possible to bribe the most senior Arab sheik. How much the more so the younger ones; and the younger ones obeyed – they did nothing on their own, without asking the sheik.
You could bribe him with a car, or the like, and he would do any thing you wanted.
Now the situation has changed to the opposite extreme. They young generation of Arabs are more fantastical and more zealous for religion, for independence, than all the sheiks, more than any in that generation.
The younger the Arab, the more zealous he is. And he can’t be bought- not with money, nor with honor. For him, this is Allah, and this is his self-sacrifice- there is nothing more glorified in his eyes than this.
Painfully and unfortunately, with respect to our own Jewish youth, the direction is just the opposite.”
End quote

Thursday 25 November 2010

A MUST WATCH, The link between Chabad and EDL‏



If good Jewish people are serious about combating and preventing the come-back of antisemitism, they must NOT sleep or feel rested UNTILL the supremacist Jewish groups and ideologies are exposed, shamed, defeated and abandoned once and for all.

Rabbi Nachum Shifren talks to the BBC , 23rd Oct 2010

This "israeli" citizen Rabbi is a Tea Party activist, a Southern California native, he is running for office ( senate candidate) in Los Angeles’s .

He was a kibbutz volunteer, and in 1977 made "aliya" . Shifren served in the IDF and received a degree in Combat Fitness Training at the Wingate Institute for Sports.

Shifren attended Toras Chayim Yeshiva in Jerusalem and Yeshivat Tomchei Tmimim in Kfar Chabad, where he received his rabbinical ordination in 1990.

US ‘Surfing Rabbi’ causes stir by joining far-right march

=================================

Quotes by Attorney Alan Dershowitz:

"The enemies of the Jewish people focus on campuses . . . . that’s why Chabad’s presence on campuses today is crucial . . . to inoculate students against the anti-semitism and apathy, and to make young people proud of being Jewish.”
Chabad houses on college campuses we are seeing a revolution in American university education which has been stimulated by Chabad. A major revolution!"
"We cannot rest until there is at least one Chabad shliach on every major college campus in the world"

This is how the supremacist Chabads infiltrate and takeover the minds of young Jewish children

++++++++++++++++++++

Manchester Lubavitch Youth Minyan Llandudno Trip


Manchester Lubavitch youth Minyan fun filled Shabbaton at Chabad Retreat Centre in Llandudno.
Rabbi Dovid Tzvi Weinman, Rabbi of the Manchester Lubavitch Youth Minyan, together with his wife Chaya, accompanied by four students of Yeshivas Lubavitch Manchester, took a group of 35 boys aged between 14 and 17 to the Chabad Retreat Centre in Llandudno for a fun filled Shabbaton.
The boys enjoyed a lively Friday night Service. They kept up the singing and dancing whilst telling stories and experiences until the early hours of Shabbos morning. After an uplifting shabbos morning service and a delicious shabbos lunch the boys were able to appreciate the beautiful Llandudno scenery with a walk.
After shabbos had ended, they, played various sports at a nearby leisure centre, followed by a Melavah Malkah back at the Retreat Centre.
The weekend was organised by Mr Gav Cohen.

Chabad Confronts Anti-Israel Activism on Campuses

by R.C. Berman - Lubavitch.com

Jeremy Izfo may soon be analyzing debt-to-earnings ratios of Fortune 500 companies, but today the economics major at Carleton University in Ottawa, Canada, is looking at Chabad on Campus's bottom line.
“There are other places that promote hanging out with Jewish people, but Chabad takes a different route. Everyone knows that Chabad is the place to go to be involved with Jewish life,” said Izfo.
The number of Chabad centers on Canadian campuses has doubled over the last five years. Today, 19 campuses benefit from Chabad representatives on site. Another eight are served by Chabad centers in the area. For Canadian university students facing growing anti-Israel sentiment and harassment from pro-Palestinian activists, Chabad's more visible presence on campus is welcome.
“There's a lot of tension between Muslim and Jewish students. We are small in number, but we have a lot of pride, and we make sure everyone knows who we are,” Izfo said.
Posters plastered around Carleton depict a mockup of an Israeli helicopter dropping bombs on a teddy-toting Palestinian toddler. The student council is run by pro-Palestinian representatives. Professors make no secret of their anti-Israel leanings. Even apolitical Jewish students feel uncomfortable and confused.
“The propaganda's logic is backwards, but convincing,” said Mrs. Yocheved Boyarsky, Chabad representative at Carleton and Ottawa U. “Students come to Shabbos dinner with us despite a very anti-Israel outlook. We encourage them to think, to question, and to see the issue through the broader view of history.”
In Ottawa, Jewish students represent only two percent of the student body. But group size does not seem mitigate the threats and taunts. York University, a commuter college near the Jewish community in Toronto, is one of the top ten universities attended by Jewish students in Canada. Yet the feeling on campus is stridently, sometimes violently anti-Israel. Last year, Jewish students at York were forced to barricade themselves inside the Hillel offices when an angry mob chased them: “Die, Jew, die, Get the hell off campus!” they screamed.

Brenda Grinsaft, a psychology major at York, is reluctant to overstate the threat. She feels safe at York, but “there is hostility” toward Jewish students. “Chabad is where Jewish students can go to feel comfortable being Jewish and proud of it,” Grinsaft said.
Countering the anti-Israel activism, Chabad at York is offering an encore round of “The Land and the Spirit” course. A probing look at the centrality of Israel to Judaism developed by the Jewish Learning Institute, the course helps students who want to understand the Jewish claim to the land of Israel, Chabad at York co-director Chanah Leah Bekerman explains.
Even students raised in traditional Jewish homes are not immune to pro-Palestinian pressure on campus. “A lot of students have parents who support Israel, actively, financially. And we have a lot of students who are pro-Israel. But a number of them are not. It is more popular to take a lefty, 'pro-peace' stand,” said Mrs. Basya Feldman, Chabad representative at Dalhousie University in Halifax, Nova Scotia.
Dr. Gil Troy, a history professor at McGill University in Montreal and author of Why I am a Zionist told Lubavitch.com that a lot is riding on the countersteps to the toxic propgaganda. “At university campuses in Canada and in the U.S., many future leaders are being educated in poisoned environments, where Israel is portrayed as the bad guy.”
Chabad's response is less about shouting down and in-your-face protests than about teaching students to connect with their own heritage, and understand the Jewish claim to the land.
Chabad at the University of Waterloo and Wilfrid Laurier University, directed by Rabbi Moshe and Rivky Goldman, introduced the J-Learn program this year, a series of mini-courses to help students acquire fundamental knowledge of Judaism. Mrs. Goldman expanded her Girls Club to offer Jewish women on campus evening classes about Judaism in a sorority-like atmosphere. Despite anti-Israel bullhorn tactics, Rabbi Goldman finds students open to different opinions.
“Canadians are polite. When I speak on Friday night, there is a greater chance that people will listen, take it seriously,” Rabbi Goldman said.
Prof. Troy promotes advocacy in his literature, but he also values Chabad's approach. “Studies show that if you have a strong connection to Judaism, you will have a strong connection to Israel.” Chabad, he explains, “creates a spiritual conversation and a cultural conversation, getting the issue away from politics,” which helps achieve the ultimate goal: supporting the Jewish homeland.
“You can't do Jewish without embracing Israel.”
The toughest time for Jewish university students on campus in recent years has been the annual “Israel Apartheid Week,” which often goes hand in hand with harassment of Jewish students. Founded in Toronto, IAW spread to 40 cities, 14 of which are in Canada.
In preparation for IAW last year, students at York University brainstormed for ideas to counter the darkness with light. They organized a Mitzvah Marathon at York, where student—Jewish and non-Jewish, alike—filled out cards, pledging to perform good deeds. They sold brownies with proceeds that went to Chabad Terror Victims Project of Israel.
Chabad at Ottawa U hosted a similar program to encourage students to perform a mitzvah. They set out a table filled with mitzvah opportunities against a backdrop of the Western Wall, right alongside the IAW row of tables.
“A lot of students tell us they felt comforted and encouraged to walk by and see our table during the week of hatred,” said Mrs. Boyarsky. Performing mitzvot is more than a nicety, a comfort zone among the vitriol. “Historically, Jews have been victorious over threats to their existence by strengthening their performance of mitzvos and staying with the Torah.”

In case you missed it:
--
nahida

zionists ‘get the hell out of Palestine’
~ Helen Thomas

To defeat the aggressors is not enough to make peace durable. The main thing is to discard the ideology that generates war. ~ Ludwig von Mises

Courage doesn't always roar. Sometimes courage is the little voice at the end of the day that says . . . I'll try again tomorrow. ~ Anne Henninghake


Anonymous said...
لا فض فوكي يا ناهده

الله يكثر من امثالك

انا بعيد نشر كل مقالاتك بأكثر من 12 موقع علمي

God bless you

i wish if i have your email

kee[p the good work
nahida the Exiled Palestinian said...
.

Thank you very much Anonymous for your comment and for helping to spread the truth, may Allah bless your work.

As for my email, you can write to me at

nahidaexiledpalestinian@gmail.com
 

Saturday 20 November 2010

Antisemitism on the rise! Really?



Jewish student caught painting Swastikas on her own door then claiming Anti-Semitic Attack


Creating a false flag anti-semitic attack to get sympathy


Police investigate anti-Semitism in Willliamsburg, and the media runs to witness, document and report this ugly hate crime of unprecedented proportions






Police investigate anti-Semitism in Willliamsburg





BROOKLYN — Police are investigating anti-Semitic messages left on the walls of a Williamsburg apartment building.


Police say someone scrawled Nazi symbols in a building primarily inhabited by Jewish residents.
Residents say they are surprised to see the symbols on the building.
No arrests have been made.

NY Rabbi Caught Up with Hedge Funds, Found Guilty

An Orthodox Jewish rabbi director of a Brooklyn, New York, religious school was found guilty by a jury on Wednesday on charges of trying to extort $4 million from SAC Capital hedge fund billionaire Steven Cohen.




The jury in U.S. District Court in Manhattan reached their verdict against Rabbi Milton Balkany in five hours of deliberations after a trial that began on November 1. Balkany was charged in February with extortion, blackmail, wire fraud and making false statements in an attempt to force Cohen to donate to his school.


Judge Denise Cote ordered Balkany's bail conditions and travel restrictions to remain in place until Monday, when he will be required to begin wearing an electronic monitoring device and be confined to his home. Balkany's sentencing was scheduled for February 18.


“I am pleased to be leaving the building with my client and we will continue to litigate important issues in this case,” the rabbi's lawyer, Benjamin Brafman, told reporters.


Brafman said at the time of Balkany's arrest that his client used bad judgment and did not act with criminal intent.


Allegations that first appeared quietly in the court record of Balkany's criminal case led to news last week that another hedge fund, FrontPoint Partners, might have traded on inside information.


Last week, U.S. prosecutors charged a French doctor, Yves Benhamou, with giving inside information to FrontPoint. Authorities charged Benhamou with tipping the hedge fund about negative results from a clinical trial that biotechnology firm Human Genome Sciences Inc was conducting for an experimental treatment for hepatitis C. The clinical trial took place in late 2007 and early 2008.


The hedge fund has put one of its top healthcare managers, Chip Skowron, on leave and said it is cooperating with authorities.


The rabbi made claims about improper trading by Skowron and FrontPoint in telephone calls with an investigator who was looking into the allegation Balkany was trying to extort money from Cohen. Prosecutors said Cohen did nothing wrong.


Transcripts of the calls were included in Balkany's trial record and partial recordings were played to the jury.


The case is USA v Balkany, U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, No. 10-441.
















This is Zionism



nahida

zionists get the hell out of Palestine’
~ Helen Thomas

To defeat the aggressors is not enough to make peace durable. The main thing is to discard the ideology that generates war.
 ~ Ludwig von Mises

Courage doesn't always roar. Sometimes courage is the little voice at the end of the day that says . . .  I'll try again tomorrow.      
 ~ Anne Henninghake
__ About anti Semitism

1 comments:

jerrygates7 said...
Thanks to Nahida for sharing how false manufacturing of hate crimes scares Jewish people and commits a false crime that empowers criminals in their pursuits of Palestine.

Anti semitism is the bedfellow of the ADL, without which there would be no need to search out and label hate crimes against Jews. Without hatred of Jewish people, there would be no insecurity in Israel, no need of walls, bantustans or the IDF or settlers, if only nobody hated the Jews, there would be peace, or so we are told by the ADL, but is this true?

First and foremost, why would someone hate a Jewish person for no reason? Why invoke the swastika to frighten a Jewish person in college? Why make people fearful in their ethnicity and traditions? Is there any valid reason for this?

The awful truth is this, when taunted or abused by anti semitism, much attention is focused on this problem, it's victims and their history, which makes the act of hatred a trip down holocaust lane with severe and forlorn images attached to this tragedy, which elicits sympathy and love for the Jewish people, but how often can this card be played in the boy who cried wolF symptomatic without deafening the ears of the villagers who must respond with support and love when the flock is threatened?

Indeed the din of anti semitism rings more hollow as the Palestinians fall prey to horrible butchery and degrading humiliation and massacres and the Palestinians are true Semites while many of the zionists are not, so whom are we kidding but ourselves when we sympathize with Jews with jobs, with homes, mothers and fathers both alive and well and with every privilege that Palestinians seek and also seeking to deny them their justice as human beings? Zionism is a debilitating scourge to Palestine to Americans to Canadians , to the UK EU and to France Germany and Turkey, why have these nations stood idly by while zionist tortures Palestine in a slow bleeding death by isolation, constriction and consumption of land? How will God forgive such cowardice in the face of injustice, crimes against children and international law, human rights ethics and Geneva's conventions, UN resolutions and ICC prosecutors amassed dossiers of evidences against apartheid Israel? How long will the nations sin and call this love for the Jews? What do you teach by turning your backs to horrible crimes but that the law is for the poor and non Jews, not for the rich or Jewish and their realms of despots and militant agressors?

What law will save the Jews tomorrow when evil does attack her flocks? How will ye fare then, brothers and sisters of zion after mocking the law, teasing it's victims and torturing their families for years with no end? I ask, what law will save you after disgraces of it's balances and lady by fools to proud to obey so they destroy tomorrow for their people, after stealing Palestine that die is cast forever, Israel is prey to warmakers and by war alone will Palestine be free that is what Jewish people say when they feign fear for advantages over non Jews. We will spit in you face until you strike us then cry foul and send you to prison as terrorists. How utterly shamful a way of life, to feel as if your life is so grand and Palestine so lowly that mockery of justice is zionism's path to greatness, Surly such a foundation is of sand and waters beating on this house when tempests arise will undermine it's cornerstone, that which the Jewish builder rejected is the head of the corner of Palestine. It is humility and honesty that bare u nations, not brashness and pride.

Friday 19 November 2010

"Nothing short of FULL LIBERATION of Palestine is acceptable!"

Friday, November 19, 2010




In this essay I would reflect on why as an exiled Palestinian, I do not believe that putting an end to zionism is an ideal solution to the Palestinian problem. Supporting "equal rights", supporting “one person, one vote”, constitutes support for the occupiers' illegitimate privilege to impose their presence in a land they conquered by war and terrorism, looted and destroyed, holding on the estate of -survivors forced into exiled -“absentees”.

“Equal rights” and the deceptive expression “one person, one vote” would finalize the conquest of Palestine. This finalization of the theft of a foreign land, would be a grave violation of the fundamentals of ethics regulating human interaction.

Worse, it would be an irreversible step backwards into the dark ages, insofar that it would constitute the first jurisprudential invalidation of most fundamentals of International Law pertaining to sovereignty and wars of aggression and conquest. Centuries of modest, painstaking progress, would be thrown out the window. The Thirteen Century Magna Carta, the Seventeenth Century Westphalia treaty, the Twentieth Century Nuremberg Principles, are the cornerstones of International Law, prohibiting Wars of Aggression, and regulating occupation.

“Equal rights”, and “one person one vote” sends the clear message to bullies, “criminals, thieves, that they get away with MURDER…. Literally” !

It is a carte blanche for bullies and aggressors to do what they like, steal, kill, colonize, rape, oppress, torture...

And that is one of the reasons why any future decision on the status of ILLEGAL COLONIZERS in Palestine should be a PALESTINIAN DECISION; they, and ONLY they, can choose whether or not, to allow some of their tormentors to stay, or not, and in which legal parameter this can happen.

The term “negotiation table” has been abused to be merely the place where the Palestinians gradually and systematically loose everything there is to loose, and they just keep on participating and giving.

This moral and legal masquerade of “Equal Rights” and “One person, one vote” is not, and never will constitute a solid basis for a lasting peace. Peace existed before the arrival of the Jewish Zionist invasion, and will exist after they leave. Palestine's sovereignty is not on the negotiation table.

Rather naively, some believe that the only solution for the Palestinian tragedy would be to de-zionise "israel". I could not disagree more.

Abandoning Zionism could potentially become even more detrimental than militant Zionism, to Palestinians' inalienable Rights, and to the Holy Land of Palestine. It would just consolidate Zionist aims, just give it a softer name. The endorsement and support of the so called “anti-zionists” to the imposed presence of “Israelis”, literally gives the “coup de grace” to Palestine.

Our allies who support the permanent stay of Jewish zionist in the land of Palestine (providing they abandon Zionism), do not realize that by doing so they are finishing the job neatly for the zionists and putting the cherry on the zionist-project pie; by giving them the approval and moral justification to keep hold of land and property acquired by unethical and illegal means

The lawsuits on behalf of Jewish people who lost property in Europe during WW2 are ongoing, almost seventy years after, yet many of our supporters cringe at the fact that we are entitled to the same, because the reinstatement and total restoration of our rights would effectively mean a full restitution of land and property from the Jewish zionist colonizers back to the original and legitimate Palestinian owners.

For me as a Palestinian as it ought to be for anyone who cares for Justice and Peace, the idea that there would be a "right" for some people to keep land and property acquired by military conquest and ethnic cleansing of genocidal proportion, is not only a regressive monstrosity, but it is also in full contravention with a set of laws emerged precisely out of WW2, and in full contradiction with any sense of moral principles.

God is not a real estate agent, nor is God a warlord, hence the "right" of Jewish colonizer is simply non-existent, whether they brandish the racist "zionist" ideology, or the pseudo-religious "God-chosen" dogma, or whether "Post-zionists" collect the "benefits" of Ariel Sharon’s atrocities against the indigenous Palestinians and environmental destruction of Palestine, the Holy Land.

Anyone who does not virulently refute the base of such non existent "right" to keep stolen land and property, is facilitating and justifying future wars of aggression and conquest, followed by colonial settlements and genocide against peaceful indigenous population.

This is nothing less than celebrating barbarity, rewarding criminality and obliteration of the very essence of human morality which mankind had worked hard to foster its progress over millennial.

When those who incessantly declaim the words "Holocaust never again" justify such lopsided views which lay the ground for future wars and genocide, the contradiction and hypocrisy becomes staggering!

Are people really so naïve and oblivious, as to not realize that by supporting “Equal Rights, one person-one vote, and by supporting the consolidation of Israelis in Palestine, even under a post-Zionist attire, de-facto corresponds to... a full support -quasi unconditional support, of the Zionist enterprise, and its ideological core which deems colonising Palestine as a “Divine and historical right” for the Jewish people ?

What does the notion of Justice, social responsibility, fair dealing mean if we are to equate criminals with victims in terms of rights to ownership of stolen property?

To advocate in favour of supposed "equal rights" between a criminal and his victim, where the criminal escapes punishment for his crimes, and is rewarded with the keeping of the loot of his aggression including total participation in decision and law making in the land occupied, is an assassination of the concept of justice, on which peaceful Civilization is built and needs to prosper


Accepting the mere declaration of abandoning Zionism and the announcement of equal rights for both without holding those responsible into account, is an utter betrayal of Palestine and the Palestinians.

The aims and rights of Palestinians are not defined by some change of zionist regime, or some vacuous declaration of abandonment of zionism. Our aim is the strict, legally and morally necessary, FULL Liberation of Palestine, and the restoration of all our rights.

During almost a century since they began to invade Palestine, the Judeo-Zionists would have had enough time to begin to notice their own crimes, and begin to exhibit signs of remorse, of respect and willingness to behave like decent human beings. Had they embraced the hospitable people of Palestine, rather than methodically annihilating them, they might have had a chance to be accepted and forgiven. Not any more, they have lost that opportunity.

Furthermore, in the context of shifting balance of power, the rest of the world begins slowly to wake up to the truth, and the Muslim world will certainly not remain lethargic forever.

People of the world are opening their eyes to the alarming level of zionist infiltration in their own affairs; governments manipulations, media control, financial corruption It is not going to be a pleasant reckoning.

Even decades of deception do not prevent karma.

Unrelenting zionist blackmail of mass genocide and world annihilation, will not bring them much support, but rather bring the world to stand up like the brave Palestinians and STOP this madness once and for all. Indubitably, the world will regurgitate those who drive for its annihilation, Samson-ists and Armageddon-ists. The world will unite and rid itself of this Frankenstein.

In the end, zionists and their associates will not find many to shed tears for them, nor will they find many open doors to welcome them. The only open doors will be the EXIT doors of expulsion out of Palestine.

Time, perhaps another couple of thousand years, might help them to learn the lesson, bring them to their senses, back into humanity.

Then and only then, only when animated by peaceful intentions, can they try to knock at Palestine's doors again. Not now, and not for a long time.

In other word, with time it became evident that the only possible outcome is the unconditional, FULL LIBERATION of Palestine!



In case you missed it:

Thursday 4 November 2010

Who is trying to bluff the Palestinians?

Thursday, November 4, 2010


A critical view of Alan Hart’s proposal to Palestinians

By Nahida the Exiled Palestinian
Alan Hart, a friend and supporter of Palestine, invited ALL Palestinians, at home and in Diaspora with all their political shades, factions and affiliations to unite and “call israel’s bluff”

July 27, 2010
He writes: (emphasis mine)
“They could do so with a joint Fatah-Hamas statement to something like this effect:
“We cannot and will not recognise Israel’s “right” to exist because it has no such right, but we are a pragmatic people and we hereby declare that we are prepared to recognise and live in permanent peace with the reality of an Israel inside its borders as they were on the eve of the 1967 war, with Jerusalem an open, undivided city and the capital of two states… We further declare that our pragmatism extends to accepting that the right of the dispossessed Palestinians to return must and will be confined to the Palestinian state, which means that many of those who wish to return will have to settle for compensation for the loss of their homes and their land.” 

Alan Hart recapitulates:

The point of the article above is only that I believe the Palestinian leadership should now say, in the most explicit terms, that most Palestinians are still prepared to live in permanent peace with an Israel inside its pre-1967 borders."

Our friend wants the Palestinians to attest their good-intention publicly, once and for all and demonstrate to the world and to the occupiers of their lands that they are only interested in peace, they "should" reassure their rapist murderers, "in the most explicit terms" that they want to "live in permanent peace" with a "Jewish state" encroached over 80% of their land!! In other words, Palestinians are strongly advised by our friend to pull their acts together, organize, unite and hurry up, sign the statement he prepared for them in which they sign off permanently their RIGHTS to their OWN historic land of Palestine. Furthermore, he wants the Palestinians to declare publicly and permanently that they are giving up their right of return!

These are precisely the demands of our enemy!
Total Surrender, nothing less nothing more, and that’s at a time when the Palestinian struggle and resistance are finally gaining global support and momentum.

By doing so, Mr. Hart reflects better his domain of interest and expertise; namely zionists and “israelis”, but not Palestine or Palestinians.
Had he any real knowledge of Palestinians, he would’ve known that Palestinians do NOT surrender.
More than a century of struggle, sacrifices and extreme anguish did not weaken their fortitude to resist, nor did it destroy or even abate their aim of return and of the liberation of all of Palestine.

Now, the question is:

Why Palestinians should NEVER recognize “israel”?

Furthermore

Why REAL friends of Palestine should NEVER insist or even ask that Palestinians recognize “israel”?

Amazingly enough, Alan Hart’s own articles prove that he knows perfectly well the answer to those questions; but he apparently assumes that Palestinians have a memory span of a fish!
On Oct 16th, 2009, he wrote: (emphasis mine)

legitimacy was the only thing the Zionists could not and cannot take from the Palestinians by force.”
“The truth of the time was that the Zionist state, which came into being mainly as a consequence of pre-planned ethnic cleansing, had no right to exist and, more to the point, could have no right to exist UNLESS … Unless it was recognized and legitimized by those who were dispossessed of their land and their rights during the creation of the Zionist state. In international law only the Palestinians could give Israel the legitimacy it craved.”

On one hand, Mr. Hart acknowledges that “israel” has no right to exist unless explicitly recognized and legitimized by the Palestinians -ONLY the Palestinians, and he also acknowledges that “israel” is craving for this recognition.

On the other hand, Mr. Hart now volunteers, on the bases of his good name, to obtain that recognition by temptation and persuasion, regardless of the miscarriage of justice that would cause, and the irreversible harm this would inflect on Palestinians.

To this effect, it is with condescension that he makes the misleading demand that ALL Palestinians should on his say-so show pragmatism and unite to recognize and legitimize the Jewish state on 80% of their land.

What would Palestinians lose if they accept Mr. Hart’s proposal? what is in there in his scheme for Palestinians?

What would happen if ALL Palestinians including Hamas and the Diaspora are CONNED into recognising “israel” within the 1967 borders, (under the pretext of “calling israel’s bluff”)?

There are two outcomes:

At best; the conscience of the “israeli” occupiers would suddenly be awakened and they would accept the Palestinian offer, in which case the Palestinians would’ve signed off their right of return, and signed away 80% of their historic land of Palestine, forever!

And at worst; the zionists would just continue to ignore the Palestinians and their lawful demands, and would clutch onto the ONLY document that would give them the legal power to legitimize their entity, namely the surrender of the Palestinians to their occupiers to achieve complete and final take over the entire land of Palestine!

By being aware that “israel’s” legitimacy is unobtainable by force, and nevertheless suggest the Palestinians should call “israel’s” bluff, i.e. recognise it within the 1967 borders, Mr. Hart in effect volunteers to achieve for the zionists the “legitimacy” they are craving for, through a final and comprehensive declaration of recognition and legitimization of the Jewish state from those very oppressed and dispossessed, the ONLY ones who could grant that legitimacy to the criminal state.
Whether at best naïve, or at worst cunning and deceptive, Mr. Hart’s suggestion would leave all Palestinian losing everything with absolutely nothing to gain.
Furthermore, under the double pretext of realism and extreme disproportion of power, Alan Hart uses intimidation to blackmail Palestinians with his “knowledge” of the “seriousness” of the zionist threat of nuclear annihilation;

“Always in my own mind is what Prime Minister Golda Meir said to me in a BBC Panorama interview and from which I quote in my book – in a doomsday situation Israel “would be prepared to take the region and the whole world down with it.”” http://www.informationclearinghouse.info/article26662.htm
It appears that Mr. Hart uses the carrot and the stick to bring Palestinians to line and trap them to surrender their rights and land, once and for all.

Knowingly or unknowingly, Mr. Hart is doing a great job on behalf of our oppressors.

His proposal serves nothing but to finalize the zionist project by achieving the permanent Jewish conquest of Palestine.

Incidentally, terminating the Palestinian human right to return to their homeland, trampling over the souls of millions who raised the banner of freedom for over a century, trashing and thrashing their sacrifices is not much of a concern to Mr. Hart.

What he worries most about is to prevent the rise of anti-Semitism, and to secure the permanent presence of a Jewish state on the occupied land of Palestine, be it as it may at the cost of slaughtering justice at the alter of the “Chosen”, and extinguishing the candle of freedom in the service of the “Light unto nations”

Mr. Hart’s proposal would trap Palestinians to become an archetype of disintegration and worse, it would offer the jurisprudential grounds justifying future wars of conquest and aggression.

What a stark contrast with the pertinent, insightful and astute suggestion offered with great sincerity by Dr. Francis Boyle, expert in International Law

"The Palestinians must sign nothing and let Israel collapse!"

With all due respect, I wonder if by enticing Palestinians to “call israel’s bluff”, was Mr. Hart trying to bluff the Palestinians?
___________________________________________________________________________________

6 comments:

jerrygates7 said...
Nahida, The Exiled Palestinian discusses Alan Hart's assertion that the Palestinians, both Hamas and Fatah, should declare eternal peace with Israel at the pre 1967 borders......

Just days ago, the people of Lebanon were asked to absorb Palestinians into Lebanon and allow for permanat status and citizenship, Now Alan Hart is prescribing a balm for reuniting Hamas and Fatah with an imaginary borderline now obliterated by separation walls . Nahida asks why these false offers must be tendered by people waiting to be accepted as members of an equal rights with full citizenship democracy in the middle east . Palestine is the name they seek for their nation but one state or two, equal rights to every aspect of this land is what Palestinians are due, if this means no recognition of Israel as a Jewish democracy, it's because the democracy is missing and the land is being hoarded by investors and squatters who have no intention of ever leaving, if Palestine accedes to these facts on the ground and imaginary pre 1967 borders, why not ask Israel to understand that what is not a meaningless border that is traversed without question by Jews and prevents free passage to Palestinians is facts on the ground reality that Alan Hart knows doesn't jive with his offer, sincere or not, what would Palestine have to gain by another meaningless writ of assistance to occupiers by acceding to unrealistic demands?
In the movie, Jenin Jenin, my heart nearly jumped out of my chest when a certain young man drew in a drag on his smoke and blew out the word ENOUGH!!! I heard God say it just as it came out of this mans mouth, his tears are our tears and Nahida cries them for all of us, let us never forget that great and small lives were snuffed out with callous disregard for Palestine in the past and things were signed which brought forth no tangible fruit for the greater rights of greater Palestine. The RIGHT OF RETURN MEANS WHAT IT SAYS, that is final, what would Israel have us do? Ask for a Arabs only Palestine after encroaching to withing the neck of Tel Aviv with every weapon of modern warfare aimed from every angle of declivity at Netenyahu and the Jews of zion? Palestinians are being wholly reasonable to demand their right of return the dream of Jews only police state Israel is not shared outside of the intangible borders of that quasi zionist entity, sorry for the bad news, but the law is the law and Jews are included.
Nadia said...
Brilliant
Anonymous said...
Who is trying to bluff the Palestinians?
lafayette sennacherib said...
" What he worries most about is to prevent the rise of anti-Semitism..."

Well, he could certainly give that impression. Funnily enough, I looked over here today because I'd just read another piece by Hart on Redress, which annoyed me so much that I thought I'd see if it was on this site, so I could comment on it. But Nahida has said most of what I was going to say. It seems to be a problem that runs through everything Hart writes. I think he means well, and for someone with his background his writing is really quite brave, but I think it may be that he has spent so long in the mainstream media that he has been thoroughly indoctrinated in the 'acceptable limits of discourse' as Chomsky puts it (sort-of), and is really quite unaware of his assumptions - I hope so anyway.


I would add that another very questionable assumption is that Israel is the only thing that jews do that could give rise to anti-semitism, though the other main thing I have in mind has a big bearing on Israel too. Of course it's 'that thing' where a mere 2% of the USA's population contains 40% (at the very least) of the billionaires, the entire board of the Federal reserve, almost the entire Obama, Bush and Clinton administrations, control all the main media, and are hugely over-represented in law (3 of the 9 supreme court judges, none of them WASPs, the majority population), academia, you name it - all the key nodes of the US state. Yet 'leftists' who agree with the unanimous evidence that there is no correlation between 'race' and IQ, and who wouldn't accept that jews are a race anyway, are quite happy to accept that this is because jews are cleverer than other people, and accept that we are destined to be ruled by them, and that's ok because they're also 'more liberal' than other people.
nahida the Exiled Palestinian said...
.
Dear lafayette

Thank you for you comment, I find it indeed unfathomable to see the reaction of some "Liberals" and "progressives", when it comes to discussing the obscene reality of the over-representation, the reactions range from total shock, and disdain for the mere uttering of these facts, to of course the outraged accusation of "antisemitism", that some one dares to talk about such a taboo.

Those who have the heart to listen to the facts or read them would come up with all sorts of bizarre "explanations", and as you might have experienced yourself, the most common is that they are "smarter", "have something special, a spark", "naturally high achievers" … etc, etc

People fail to see how odd these explanations are, when challenged with the facts that:
a) race intelligence is a meaningless concept from any serious scientific viewpoint,
b) they are not even a race to start with,
c) the inherent racism in the belief of the existence of a group with higher IQ

http://uprootedpalestinians.blogspot.com/2010/07/nahida-breaking-taboos.html

Looking at the obvious, which indicates the manifestation of a tribal loyalty that gives rise to preferential and favoured treatment to members of the group, allegiances that makes the promotion of each other surpasses any other qualification or talent.

Also the organized fishing, capturing and sponsoring of those whom they want to promote as future leaders and representatives, please have a good look at this:

AIPAC: We make sure that pro-Israel candidates ‘take over’ government

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6jDIfFEUrcQ&feature=player_embedded

.
lafayette sennacherib said...
Nahida - that Breaking Taboos piece is brilliant. Sorry I missed it. Just last week on another thread on this site someone accused me of bringing up the old Shylock caricature for suggesting that jews' longstanding dominance of international finance, and their being first in the door with fractional reserve banking, might have something to do with their ability to circumvent the USA's Civil Rights laws and 'favour their own'.
Some jews who I don't doubt for a minute are deeply appalled by Israel still seem to have a 'place in the corner of their eye' where they dare not look, maybe because of some deep programming. The gentile 'left' of course are thoroughly indoctrinated with 'anti-nazism'. Most of them scarcely bother to call themselves socialists anymore, just anti-nazis, though the 'nazis' have never amounted to more than a few hundred football hooligans with a tiny sprinkling of occultist nerd Hitler fans.

But now the far-right has discovered that if they learn to swallow their disgust and swear loyalty to Israel, and concentrate on 'Paki-bashing', they get a better hearing from the mainstream media, and start getting some electoral success, not to mention 'funding'. A brilliant account of this is given by Israel Shamir (who I have some reservations about) in this interview:

http://www.israelshamir.net/English/right-wing_zionists.htm


Someone who certainly has that 'place in the corner of the eye' is Tony Greenstein, who you may remember instigated that over-the-top campaign against Gilad Atzmon. I used to think Tony was a Mossad agent, but I've come to believe he's sincere but eccentric with a huge ego. I've got to hand it to him though for these 2 pieces, on the chair of the UK zionist federation being caught (photos) marching with the fascist English Defence League. Don't miss the comments- they're hilarious.




http://azvsas.blogspot.com/2010/10/setting-edl-cat-among-zionist-pigeons.html

http://azvsas.blogspot.com/2010/09/jonathan-hoffman-disappears-its-this.html